Don't Settle For Me

Don't Settle For Me
Performer(s): Heather Davis and Greg SerranoFirst Appearance: ""I'm Going on a Date with Josh's Friend!""
Written by: Rachel Bloom and Adam SchlesingerGenre: Acoustic

Come on dude don't settle for me!
— Heather

"Don't Settle For Me" is the second reprise of the song "Settle For Me" this time sung by Heather Davis to Greg Serrano (who also takes part in the song). Heather realized her boyfriend at the time was in love with Rebecca Bunch and confronted Greg with the truth in song. She also broke up with him refusing to be his second choice. Heather encouraged Greg to confess his feelings to the true object of his affections. This second reprise was first heard in the Season One episode "Josh and I Go to Los Angeles!".

The song with lyricsEdit

"Settle For Me (reprise II) (aka "Don't Settle For Me")"01:22

"Settle For Me (reprise II) (aka "Don't Settle For Me")"


Don't settle for me


Come on dude
Don't settle for me
Trust me I know guys
And that look in your eyes
Means your in love!

Love? Who are you all of a sudden?

Shut up and listen to my wise reprise.

We've had some fun together

Hold on a second Heather!

But I need, like, so much more!
I'm way too badass to be
Someone you settle for!

Go see her, okay?


  • This is essentially the second reprise of the song "Settle For Me"; the original song was performed by Greg accompanied by Rebecca, the first reprise (or "Settle For Him") was done with Rebecca by herself. Both of those versions were in the episode "I'm Going on a Date with Josh's Friend!". Unlike the previous ones, the third song is a more stripped down version featuring only an acoustic guitar to accompany the vocals.
  • In the following episode "Josh is Going to Hawaii!", Heather admits to Greg that this song was a test to see if he was truly invested in thier relationship. He failed the test when he chose to go see Rebecca and broke Heather's heart in the process.
Crazy Ex-Girlfriend Songs
Season 1 Songs

· "Crazy Ex-Girlfriend Theme Song"
· "West Covina (song)"
· "The Sexy Getting Ready Song"
· "I'm So Good At Yoga"
· "Feelin' Kinda Naughty"
· "Face Your Fears"
· "I Have Friends"
· "A Boy Band Made Up of Four Joshes"
· "Settle For Me"

· "Sex with a Stranger"
· "I Love My Daughter"
· "I'm a Good Person"
· "I Give Good Parent"
· "What'll It Be"
· "Sexy French Depression"
· "His Status is...Preferred"
· "Where's the Bathroom?"
· "California Christmastime"
· "Women Gotta Stick Together"
· "Dear Joshua Felix Chan"

· "Having a Few People Over"
· "Put Yourself First"
· "Textmergency"
· "Where Is The Rock?"
· "You Stupid Bitch"
· "Group Hang"
· "Romantic Moments"
· "Cold Showers"
· "JAP Battle"
· "Flooded with Justice
· "Gettin' Bi"
· "I'm The Villain In My Own Story"

· "Dream Ghost"
· "I Could If I Wanted To"
· "Clean Up on Aisle 4"
· "Heavy Boobs"
· "I Gave You a UTI"
· "Angry Mad"
· "Oh My God I Think I Like You"
· "After Everything I've Done For You (That You Didn't Ask For)"
· "One Indescribable Instant"

Season 2 Songs

· "Just a Girl in Love"
· "Love Kernels"
· "We Should Definitely Not Have Sex Right Now"
· "Maybe This Dream"
· "Greg's Drinking Song"
· "Ping Pong Girl"
· "The Math of Love Triangles"
· "It Was a S*** Show"

· "We Tapped That Ass"
· "Makey Makeover"
· "Thought Bubbles"
· "Triceratops Ballet"
· "Friendtopia"
· "Stuck in the Bathroom"
· "Research Me Obsessively"
· "You Go First"
· "So Maternal"

· "Duh!"
· "Who's The New Guy?"
· "George's Turn"
· "We'll Never Have Problems Again"
· "Remember That We Suffered"
· "Santa Ana Winds"
· "Let's Have Intercourse"

· "You’re My Best Friend (And I Know I’m Not Yours)"
· "Man Nap"
· "(Tell Me I'm Okay) Patrick"
· "Period Sex"
· "What a Rush to Be a Bride"

Season 3 Songs

· "Where's Rebecca Bunch?"
· "Let's Generalize About Men"
· "You Do/You Don’t Want To Be Crazy"
·I've Got My Head In The Clouds
·Strip Away My Conscience
· "The Buzzing From The Bathroom"
· "The Moment Is Me"
·I Go To The Zoo

· "Scary Scary Sexy Lady"
· "The End of The Movie"
· "Maybe She's Not Such A Heinous Bitch After All"
· "I Feel Like This Isn't About Me"
·A Diagnosis
·This Is My Movement
·The Very First Penis I Saw
·My Friend's Dad



Crazy Ex-Girlfriend Reprises

· "West Covina (I)"
· "West Covina (II)"
· "Settle For Me (I)"
· "Settle For Me (II)"

· "I'm a Good Person (silent)"
· "The Sexy Gonna Do It Song"
· "The Trent Is Getting Ready Song"

· "I Have Friends (reprise)"
· "Flooded with Justice (reprise)
· "I Could If I Wanted To (reprise)"
· "Thought Bubbles (reprise)"

· "The Math of Love Triangles (reprise)"
· "Rebecca's Reprise"
·"After Everything You Made Me Do (That You Didn’t Ask For)"

Crazy Ex-Girlfriend Album Bonus tracks

· "Sex Toys"

· "It's Not Difficult To Define Miss Douche"

· "Santa Ana Winds 6 A.M." (Demo)

· "I'm Just A Girl In Love" (featuring Adam Schlesinger)

Ad blocker interference detected!

Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.