You're not that nice to me and you're weird and I tell myself to stop thinking about you but every time you show up its like BOOM! Feelings!
— Greg to Rebecca
Heather Davis is in her junior college abnormal Psychology class presenting to everyone a case study she made on her next door neighbor Rebecca Bunch. The teacher reprimands her for describing her subject in negative non-clinical terms. She scoffs at this believing the words to be appropriate and wonders aloud about Rebecca's origins (♫ Crazy Ex-Girlfriend Theme Song ♫). Over at the skate park, Paula tries to help Rebecca practice skate boarding so she can impress Josh. They are interrupted by a phone call from Rebecca's mother who criticizes her impulsive move to California. Hurt by her mom's disapproval she leaves to wallow in self pity. On her way back home Rebecca bumps into Heather who is returning from school.
Heather suggests that to cheer herself up Rebecca should use an online dating service to score a casual hook-up with a stranger. She arranges a date with a guy named Jason and takes him home (♫ Sex with a Stranger ♫). However, she is inspired by another butter commercial to make healthier choices and kicks Jason out. Meanwhile at Home Base, Chris is egging Greg to go through with his end of a deal they made to ask a girl they like out. Josh shows up and tells Greg about needing to find a job soon or he'll have to work at his father's radiology lab. Josh learns from Chris about his pact with Greg and also encourages him to ask Rebecca out. When Rebecca herself shows up she announces her intentions to make healthier, better choices from now on.
Upon hearing this Greg decides to ask her out but she's reluctant to accept (♫ Settle For Me ♫). Taking a break from job hunting, Josh heads to his favorite hang out the Aloha Tech Center and finds out that they are hiring. He grabs an application and heads to Whitefeather & Associates to get Rebecca to help him fill out an essay portion. While he's there he tries out her treadmill desk and convinces Rebecca to go out with Greg. Sometime later she goes with Greg to the West Covina Taco festival. Despite her initial trepidation she enjoys herself on the date. Meanwhile, Josh's application is rejected by the the store's manager specifically because of the pompous essay Rebecca wrote.
At the taco festival, Rebecca convinces Greg to go a Guacamole competition and they split up to sample the two finalists submissions. She meets a male competitor named Xander who is also a practicing vegan and flirts a little with Rebecca. When she reunites with Greg he teases her about her sudden shift in life style choices. Seeing how upset she got he apologizes for hurting her feelings and the matter seems to be resolved. Rebecca excuses herself to use the port-a-potty and while inside struggles with whether or not to be with Greg (♫ Settle For Me (reprise) ♫). Her anxiety causes her to break her vegan diet and is caught by Xander eating a beef burrito. She impulsively decides to abandon Greg and take Xander home with to have sex.
A furious Greg confronts her at her home having just seen Xander leaving her place. He tells her how appalled he is at her behavior and disappointed she never gave him a real chance. Meanwhile, Josh is told by the store manger Alex that he didn't get the job at Aloha specifically because of the essay portion Rebcca wrote. He is forced to get a job at his father's Radiology lab and has to deal with it's depressing atmosphere and patients like Irving. He posts a photo of his first day on his Instagram account. Rebecca sees the photo and drags Josh back to the Aloha Tech Center to confront the manager. She gives an impassioned speech and actually convinces the manager to hire Josh. Afterwards, Josh thanks Rebecca and tells her he's glad she moved to West Covina.
Later, Paula and Rebecca are in the Whitefeather & Associates break room eating bacon covered glazed donuts. Rebecca ignores a phone call from her mother and Paula congratulates her for making a healthy choice. Back at Junior college, Heather is presenting her case study of Rebecca again but this time is far less critical. She is unwilling to put Rebecca's psychosis in definitive psychological terms claiming she defies traditional classification. Her teacher disagrees with Heather's assessment believing Rebecca to have serious mental health issues. Heather responds that she'd rather just be Rebecca's friend and not put any labels her. She then decides to quit the class and walks out.
At the "Truly Happy Truly Butter" offices an executive at the company speaks with the head of the marketing campaign Gary. The latest advertisements have been a huge success and have increased sales of thier product. While he is happy with the results he is concerned by the advertising copy. The various tag lines about making the right choices and questioning one's happiness hints at personal issues Gary might be having. When asked about it Gary admits he left his wife for a prostitute and breaks down crying.
Chris, Greg's middle school friend and customer at Home Base, returns in this episode. His previous appearance was in "I Hope Josh Comes to My Party!" and his next appearance is in "My First Thanksgiving With Josh!".
Joseph Chan, Josh Chan's father, debuts in this episode. His next appearance is in the episode "My First Thanksgiving With Josh!".
Alex, the manager of the Aloha Tech Center, debuts in this episode. His next appearance is in the Season Two episode "Where Is Josh's Friend?".